Auction Activity Rises, but the Clearance Rate Tells a Softer Story

More homes went to auction across the combined capitals last week, but a much smaller share cleared. The preliminary clearance rate fell to 44.0%, down 7.5 percentage points from the previous week’s preliminary result of 51.5%. Cotality describes this as the lowest preliminary result since April 2020.

Auction numbers rose 11.4% week on week to 1,888, yet remained 41.1% below the same period last year. That combination matters: more properties came forward than the week before, but the increase in activity did not translate into stronger clearance results. The rate was also below the reported spring-to-date average of 50.4%.

The broader indicators are not pointing in one direction either. Capital-city home values fell 1.4% over the latest 28 days, while advertised sale listings were 20% higher than a year earlier. At the same time, new listings were 18.4% lower year on year. These figures describe a market with a larger pool of advertised properties but fewer newly listed homes, alongside recent value declines.

There is no single national story here: auction outcomes and value movements vary considerably by city. For buyers and sellers alike, local conditions and the type of property matter more than the combined-capital headline.

What This Means For

First Home Buyers

The weaker auction clearance rate and higher total advertised stock may give buyers more room to assess options than a high-clearance, low-stock market would. But the evidence is not uniform: Sydney’s preliminary rate was 48.1%, Melbourne’s 47.8%, and Brisbane’s 25.3%. A national figure cannot tell you how competitive a particular suburb or price bracket will be.

Recent value falls may also be relevant when comparing properties, but they are broad index movements, not a guarantee that an individual home has become cheaper by the same amount. Careful comparisons remain important.

Investors

Values and rents are moving differently. The combined-capital Home Value Index was down 6.1% over 12 months, while the national median rent was $715 a week in October, 5.3% higher than a year earlier. That contrast is worth noting, but it does not establish the return on any particular property: rental growth, purchase price and local conditions all differ.

Rental listings across the combined capitals were 7.6% higher year on year, another reminder that conditions vary across the housing market. Investors should avoid treating either the national rent figure or auction results as a substitute for assessing a specific location and property.

Up-Sizers

For households selling one home and buying another, falling value indices may affect both sides of the move. The difference between local markets matters: Sydney and Melbourne recorded sharper annual value declines than Adelaide and Perth. Meanwhile, higher total sale listings across the capitals may mean a broader advertised pool, though availability depends on the area and property sought.

Auction Clearances In Select Markets

Among the larger auction markets, Sydney recorded 716 auctions and a preliminary clearance rate of 48.1%. Melbourne had 692 auctions and cleared at 47.8%, after an 11.3 percentage-point weekly decline. Brisbane’s rate was lower at 25.3% across 235 auctions, even as its auction count rose from the previous week. Adelaide recorded 41.3% across 148 auctions, while Canberra was at 34.9% from 80 auctions.

The softer combined result also masks local variation. In Sydney, Ryde recorded a 65.6% preliminary rate, while Northern Beaches was 21.3%. Melbourne’s Inner East was at 58.9%, compared with 39.4% in the Outer East. Regional results also differed: Newcastle and Lake Macquarie recorded 75.0% from 25 auctions, while the Gold Coast was at 20.6% from 86. These are preliminary weekly snapshots, and the smaller regional samples warrant particular care.

Perth’s rate was not reported because results had been collected for only eight of 16 auctions. Preliminary results can change as more outcomes are collected.

Key Market Indicators

Indicator Latest Comparison
Combined-capital auctions 1,888 Up 11.4% week on week; down 41.1% year on year
Preliminary clearance rate 44.0% Down 7.5 percentage points week on week
Capital-city sale listings 94,059 total; 23,635 new Total up 20.0%; new down 18.4% year on year
Home Value Index, combined capitals -1.4% over 28 days -6.1% over 12 months
National median rent $715 per week Up 5.3% over 12 months; data to October

The listings figures cover the four weeks ending 15 November. Total listings include new properties and homes advertised previously, while new listings exclude properties advertised within the prior 75 days. The gap between the two measures suggests the current advertised pool is larger than a year ago even though fewer new properties entered it during the latest four-week period. It is a useful distinction when considering buyer choice, but it does not establish how quickly any individual property will sell.

Questions We’re Hearing

Does the higher auction count mean buyer demand is strengthening?

Not by itself. Auction volumes rose from the previous week, but the preliminary clearance rate fell, and the number of auctions remained well below the same period last year. The figures show more auction activity than the previous week, not a clear broad-based improvement in results.

Are home values falling everywhere?

No. The combined-capital index was down 6.1% over 12 months, but city results varied: Sydney was down 10.6% and Melbourne 8.2%, while Adelaide was up 2.5% and Perth 1.5%. The combined figure is an overview, not a description of every city or property.

Are there more homes available to buy?

The report counted 94,059 total capital-city sale listings over the latest four weeks, 20% more than a year earlier. New listings were lower over the same comparison. Together, those measures indicate a larger advertised stock pool alongside a slower flow of new listings, rather than a simple surge in newly listed homes.

The Orchard Lending View

This week’s clearest signal is the separation between activity and success at auction. More properties were taken to auction than the week before, but the preliminary share that cleared fell to 44%. That is a meaningful change in the weekly snapshot, though one week cannot establish how conditions will develop from here.

Other measures reinforce the need to look beyond auctions. The combined-capital value index has fallen over both the latest 28 days and 12 months, but annual movements range from declines in Sydney and Melbourne to modest gains in Adelaide and Perth. Meanwhile, sale listings are higher overall year on year even as new listings are lower. These signals describe different parts of the market, not a single measure of buyer demand.

For buyers, the data supports a considered, property-by-property approach rather than assuming every market has softened equally. Sellers should recognise that preliminary clearance rates are weak in several capitals, while local sub-regions still differ substantially. For homeowners and investors, the broad value and rent figures offer context, not a forecast or a property-specific outcome. The extent to which this week’s auction result persists remains uncertain.

What We’ll Be Watching Next Week

Auction activity: We’ll watch both the number of auctions held and the updated clearance results. If activity changes while clearance rates move differently, that will help clarify whether this week’s gap was a short-term result or part of a continuing pattern.

Differences between markets: Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane produced distinct results, and sub-regional outcomes were wider still. Further results will show whether those local contrasts remain evident.

Listings and values: The next useful comparison is whether total advertised stock and new listings continue to move in opposite directions, alongside the short-term home-value trend.

The main uncertainty is whether the sharp fall in preliminary clearance rates will persist as more auction results are collected and the next week’s activity unfolds. The combined-capital figure is worth tracking, but local differences remain central to interpreting it.